| Platinum | Farmer's Table |
| Gold | Frank and Spoon |
| Silver | Taste Unlimited |
| Bronze | Viking Burger |
| Top Pick | Cozzy's Comedy Club & Tavern |
| Top Pick | Danny's Deli Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Grandstand's Grill |
| Top Pick | Hilton Tavern Brewing Co. |
| Top Pick | Rocky Mount BBQ |
| Top Pick | Schooners Grill |