| Platinum | Harpoon Larry's Oyster Bar |
| Gold | Fin Seafood |
| Silver | Surf Rider Restaurant |
| Bronze | Captain Chuck-A-Mucks Sandbar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Bubba's Shrimp Shack Grafton |
| Top Pick | Crab Shack |
| Top Pick | Mr. Boil - Cajun Seafood & Poke Bowl |
| Top Pick | Pier 88 |
| Top Pick | Schlesinger's |
| Top Pick | Schooners Grill |