| Platinum | Vinny's Pizza and Pasta |
| Gold | Dino's Pizza Shop |
| Silver | Pizza Sam |
| Bronze | Annas Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Azzurri Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Brickhouse Tavern |
| Top Pick | Dough Haus |
| Top Pick | Gus's New York Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little Vinny's to-Go |
| Top Pick | Vinny's On Oyster Point |