| Platinum | Farmer's Table |
| Gold | Circa 1918 |
| Silver | Gus's Hot Dog King |
| Bronze | Dino's Pizza Shop |
| Top Pick | Al Frescos |
| Top Pick | Byrd's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Danny's Deli Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rocky Mount BBQ |
| Top Pick | Schlesinger's |
| Top Pick | Smoke BBQ Restaurant & Bar |